🤯 Why China South City Collapsed Despite Government Backing

Together with

Hey Founders,

Welcome to The Runway Ventures — a weekly newsletter where I deep dive into failed startup stories to help you become the top 1% founder by learning from their mistakes with actionable insights.

Today’s story is about how a China’s state-backed company collapsed because of these 2 deadly mistakes. Let’s get to it! 🚀

If you’re a founder and looking to amplify your startup story (be it your journey, mistakes, and learnings) for branding or finding your next customers and investors, then The Runway Ventures is your distribution channel.

🫡 You’ll get:

• Podcast where I’ll ask great questions for you to share your startup journey (yes — the raw and untold story)

• Full deep dive of your story (sent to 15,700+ newsletter subscribers who are mainly founders + investors in Asia).

• LinkedIn posts to share your story with my ~57k+ followers.

It’s not free, but it’s not expensive either.

I’ve spent ~2 years building a highly curated founder community in Asia. And I can guarantee that you won’t find this niche and engaged founder community anywhere else.

• The worst case scenario — 73k+ founders + investors in Asia know who you are and what you’re building for future partnerships.

• The best case scenario — You get new customers and investors.

Either way, it’s a win for you. So if you’re keen, book a call here and I’ll see if it’s a good fit.

PS - You must have a good story to tell and be open to sharing your mistakes and learnings.

☠️ 1 Failed Startup: China South City

🚀 The Rise of China South City

🇨🇳 Founded by a group of 5 seasoned entrepreneurs in 2002, China South City created massive integrated logistics and trade centers that would revolutionise how China did business with the world.

• The Problem — 📦 China was becoming the world's factory, but the logistics infrastructure was fragmented and inefficient.

  • Suppliers of things like textiles, electronics components, plastics, paper packaging, and metals were scattered all over the place.

  • Manufacturers and distributors struggled with sourcing materials as they had to hop between different markets, deal with inconsistent services and inefficient logistics.

• The Solution — 🏭 China South City built massive, integrated logistics and trade complexes — centralising multiple industries, providing warehousing, trade, and exhibition services all in one location with a scalable model.

  • They called this “One‑Body‑with‑Two‑Wings” model.

    • One Body — Large integrated logistics and trade centers

    • Two Wings — Commercial ancillary and residential services

  • This model streamlined sourcing, improved efficiency, and revamped how industrial materials were traded and distributed in China.

🤝🏻 Suppliers loved having a ready marketplace, and buyers loved the convenience of finding everything in one place.

At its peak, China South City went public on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange in September 2009, raising HK$2.916 billion. The Hong Kong public offering was over-subscribed 33 times — that's insane demand.

🇨🇳 Thanks to the success in Shenzhen and fundraising from IPO, China South City replicated the model across China, setting up giant logistics and wholesale complexes in places like Nanning, Xi’an, Nanchang, Zhengzhou, Harbin, Hefei, and more.

• Manufacturers and distributors were flocking to these centers.

• The company made money by selling and leasing space, while also offering services like warehousing, logistics, and even running outlet malls and trade exhibitions on-site.

• Business was booming at that time.

🔥 The ultimate validation came when Tencent invested HK$1.5 billion for a 9.9% stake. This wasn't just money — it was a strategic partnership with one of China's biggest tech companies to integrate online and offline commerce.

📈📈📈 After the Tencent deal was announced, China South City’s stock price skyrocketed to an all-time high at HK$4.72 in 2014.

That’s it.

A proven business model, a successful IPO behind it, big-name investors (with state backing), rapid expansion, and a grand vision to modernise China’s industrial supply chain…

🏔️ China South City had made it to the top.

📉 The Fall of China South City

Sadly, things started to go wrong in the years that followed.

🏦 After years of over-expansion and borrowing to build massive trade hubs, the company was crushed by China’s property downturn.

Even state-backed bailouts couldn’t stop the bleeding, as defaults piled up and cash reserves ran dry. By August 2025, a Hong Kong court ordered its liquidation, making it the first state-backed developer to collapse in China’s real estate crisis.

📌 Here’s what happened to China South City:

🙏🏻 In short, China South City’s collapse was caused by over-expansion, heavy debt, and an unforgiving market downturn.

The company grew fast and borrowed big, assuming that trade center sales and rentals would keep generating cash. But when the property cycle turned and China’s economy slowed, they couldn’t sell units fast enough or high enough to cover their debt payments.

The saddest part? China South City's original vision was actually brilliant and ahead of its time.

In a different economic environment, they might have become one of China's greatest success stories. Instead, they became a cautionary tale about the perils of timing, leverage, and the limits of government support in a capitalist market.

Want to learn more about China South City’s downfall?

• State-backed developer China South City gets liquidation order

• South City Is First Chinese State-Backed Builder Hit With Winding-Up Order Since Property Slump Began

⚠️ 2 Mistakes

Mistake 1: Drowning in debt without a safety net

China South City’s entire model was capital-intensive: buy land, build enormous trade complexes, and only later generate cash by selling or leasing space. That meant heavy upfront spending with long payback cycles.

🤑 Instead of pacing growth with internally generated revenue, they leaned heavily on debt financing:

• Bonds

• Bank loans

• Short-term borrowing

🦄 At its peak, the company’s liabilities hit HK$60.9 billion (~US$7.7B), but by the end of 2024, they had only HK$40 million (~US$5M) in cash left. That’s like trying to run a unicorn startup with $1,000 in your bank account while owing $200,000 to the bank. When the property market cooled and unit sales slowed, they simply didn’t have enough cash to service interest payments.

Even state help couldn’t save them. In 2021, Shenzhen’s state-owned group injected HK$1.9B to pay off some debts, but it barely scratched the surface.

Defaults started piling up in 2024, and once bondholders lost trust, the spiral was unstoppable.

Mistake 2: Scaled too fast

China South City nailed its first mega trade hub in Shenzhen. It worked because Shenzhen was already a manufacturing powerhouse with strong demand from textile, electronics, and industrial suppliers.

🏭🏭🏭 But instead of doubling down and optimising there, they went on an expansion blitz, building seven trade hubs across China — in Nanning, Xi’an, Nanchang, Zhengzhou, Harbin, Hefei, and beyond.

Here’s the catch: not every city had Shenzhen-level demand.

• Some of these hubs were built in regions with less industrial activity.

• Many tenants didn’t show up in droves as expected.

• Occupancy rates in smaller cities lagged, and China South City had to offer heavy discounts and incentives just to fill space.

📈 In short, they scaled ahead of demand, assuming “build it and they will come”. But unlike e-commerce or SaaS, where marginal expansion costs are low, here every mistake meant billions locked in concrete.

🧠 3 Lessons Learned

Lesson 1: Growth on debt is a double-edged sword

Debt amplifies both growth and failure. 

If revenue keeps pace, you look brilliant. If it slows, you’re trapped.

Lesson 2: Validate demand before you scale

China South City scaled as if demand was guaranteed nationwide. But instead of validating if suppliers needed such a hub in each city, they just assumed growth would follow supply.

Spoiler: it didn’t.

Lesson 3: Be ruthless about business model resilience

How?

⚠️ At first glance, China South City’s model looked brilliant — build massive physical hubs, sell/lease units, and add logistics and exhibition services. But here’s the weakness — it was a fragile business model:

• Heavy Capital Dependence: Required billions in upfront construction.

• Low Agility: Once you’ve built a mega trade center, you can’t pivot quickly if demand falls.

• Revenue Cyclicality: Depended on property sales and leases, which are highly sensitive to market cycles.

• External Shocks: Vulnerable to both macro shifts (China’s property downturn) and micro shifts (suppliers moving online).

‼️ By the time e-commerce platforms like Alibaba Wholesale and 1688.com gave suppliers cheaper, digital alternatives, China South City’s model looked outdated.

Instead of reinventing itself aggressively, it tried to bolt on online services (via Tencent partnership) while still dragging the weight of its debt-heavy, capital-intensive model.

💃 Rate Today’s Edition

That’s all for today

Thanks for reading. I hope you enjoyed today's issue. More than that, I hope you’ve learned some actionable tips to build and grow your business.

You can always write to me by simply replying to this newsletter and we can chat.

See you again next week.

- Admond

Disclaimer: The Runway Ventures content is for informational purposes only. Unless otherwise stated, any opinions expressed above belong solely to the author.